Paragon, an Israeli company Spyware claiming to act as a “moral” surveillance seller, faced control when Italy was caught earlier this year using Paragon tools to spy on the phones of two journalists. Paragon responded with the cutting of Italy from its surveillance products, making the first Spyware company to ever call publicly one of its customers after abusing its products.
Now, Paragon can face a new moral dilemma: regardless of whether it allows ICE agents to use its spyware.
A A $ 2m -year contract This Paragon signed in September 2024 with US immigration and customs imposition (ICE) remains under review and has not yet come into force and Paragon has not so far delivered investigations into the home of Ice with spyware tools, the company told Techcrunch.
Since taking over its duties in January, Trump’s administration has authorized ICE to rank large-scale immigration in all the US, leading to the detention of thousands of immigrants-and many American citizens-partially partially Thanks to data stored in federal databases and using technology provided by Govtech Giant Palandist. Given that the ice is ready to take A significantly larger budget Following the passage of Trump’s Big Beautiful Bill, Spyware could serve as a powerful surveillance tool in Trump’s administration immigration operations.
With two months left before the contract expires, Paragon can never supply its spyware on ice. But until the contract is exhausted on September 29, the US government could approve it at any time, forcing Paragon to make a decision on the use of its tools in US territories.
At the moment, the company does not want to talk about this dilemma at all. When asked by TechCrunch, Paragon would not say what she intends to do if the contract passes the revision or clarify what would happen to her relationship with Ice if the contract proceeds.
Contact us
Do you have more information about Paragon? From a non-work device, you can contact Lorenzo Franceschi-bicchierai safely on the signal on +1 917 257 1382, or via the telegraph and keybase @lorenzofb or email. You can also contact TechCrunch via securedrop.
Paragon’s contract with Ice was paused by the signature of bureaucracy. Internal Security issued an almost impaired order in order to revise whether the contract complied Executive command of the Biden era. The order restricts US government agencies from the use of commercial spyware that could (or have) be abused by foreign governments to violate human rights or target Americans abroad.
At that time, A Biden administration employee told Wired That the US government had “immediately involved” the leading leadership in internal security, which houses ICE, to determine if the contract fulfilled the requirements of the executive order.
Nine months later, the Paragon contract with Ice remains in a vacuum and officials at the Trump White House had no information about its situation.
Trump Abigail Jackson’s administration spokesman reported TechCrunch questions in the homeland and will not comment when asked about the position of Trump’s administration about the Biden Spyware executive order, which remains in place.
A spokesman for internal security and Ice did not give comments when he comes in contact with TechCrunch.
Spyware companies have historically cautious to name their customers in any context, often for fear of reputation or risking lucrative government contracts. Following the revelation of WhatsApp earlier this year that about 90 of its users, including journalists and dissident human rights, had targeted with Paragon’s Spyware, the company tried to distance itself. Paragon Executive President John Fleming told TechCrunch then that he only sells “a selected group of world democracies – mainly in the United States and its allies”.
In other words, Paragon wanted people to know that they would sell to government clients and their response to the Italian scandal seems to reinforce the position of the company.
But in the name of a moral seller spyware, Paragon put himself in to judge who he is dealing with. In this way, the company also opened the door for others to control its government customers and their morals – whether it is the Italian government or the ice. As governments and leaders change over time, Paragon may face the choice to have to reassess who they work with.
“Given the recording of administration attacks on human rights and civil society organizations, we hope that Paragon will review the agreement,” said Michael De Dora, US defense manager in Access Now, a non -profit organization worked to expose spyware.
